Is EHU metering a good investment?

GEandGJE replied on 28/11/2022 17:23

Posted on 28/11/2022 17:23

I was going to post this in the thread that has been Deleted User as a number of folk were saying that EHU Metering would make pitch prices cheaper, so Let's play the You Said, We Listened and Implemented game. This is my view based on my experience as an IT Infrastructure Project Manager and in IT Procurement.  To satisfy the We don't want EHU and want cheaper pitch prices group of people, the We only want to pay for the electricity we use group of people and the I'll pay whatever as I'm on holiday group of people, the clubs only option is to move to metered usage. How does the club do that and what investment would be needed. Lets estimate that the club has over 10,000 pitches with an average of 2 hookups per bollard that's 5,000 bollards that will need to be modified and/or replaced and some of those will need groundwork undertaken for new cabling etc, it will require  putting all pitches out of action and subsequent loss of income whilst the work takes place. This can't all be done at once and I think that a 5 year rollout period would be a stretch and it would take a dedicated team at HQ to manage. They would need to procure equipment, electrical installation teams, groundwork teams, IT systems and software to operate the metering and payments, negotiate contracts with all the power companies who supply the club sites and negotiate with any land owners. I don't think you would get much change from a £5 million investment of the clubs (our) money. Issues that the club would need to consider 1) leased sites where the land owner doesn't give permission for the work to be carried out or the lease will soon come to an end 2) the price per kW from each of the power suppliers will vary depending on contract length and renewal dates, so do they average that price out across all sites or do you have different EHU costs in different areas of the network 3) do you factor the suppliers standing charge into the  metered cost,  4) the club would need to move to a credit card only payment system where the payment for EUH used is automatically deducted at the end of your stay 5) a central dispute resolution team, as there will always be people who will challenge the bill and that shouldn't be the on site teams and finally the biggest question for the club, 6) what return on investment will the club get. I doubt very much that the savings made from the electricity used would come close to the investment needed therefore the remaining investment would need to come from reserves and most likely recouped from increased pitch prices. Lastly this would give the club a very inconsistent offering with not all sites offering metered EUH, the cost of EHU could vary from site to site and an even bigger price variance across the network. Not a very good Business Case in my view, in terms of both investment and inconvenience to the membership so I can't see it happening I'm afraid.

replied on 29/11/2022 11:56

Posted on 29/11/2022 11:35 by SteveL

I think there were 2KW versions. We bought our Cadiz in 2014 and I seem to recall the 3KW Alde was was advertised as a new system. 

Posted on 29/11/2022 11:56

The user and all related content has been Deleted User

JVB66 replied on 29/11/2022 11:57

Posted on 29/11/2022 11:50 by

If it is the case that John I do wonder why CC Ltd are not installing metered unit instead of the "latest bollards" as you put it.  An opportunity missed.

Posted on 29/11/2022 11:57

Maybe bollards that are meter compatible are what are being installed on sites being refurbished but on sites not due  refurbishment. a "cheaper" but modification possible type is being installed if replacing damaged or faulty bollards 

peedee replied on 29/11/2022 11:58

Posted on 29/11/2022 11:58

Agreed....it is a sledgehammer....most either want EHU or they don't.

I also agree but it would be a real about turn for the Club to change its mind and have a price depending whether you hook up or not. THey have consistently refused to do this over the years since 2003 when there were many protests over the introduction of an inclusive price.

I remain in favour of metering even though I would use EHU but in probablity, even in winter, just to keep the battery charged.

peedee

mickysf replied on 29/11/2022 12:01

Posted on 28/11/2022 18:22 by Takethedogalong

It won’t make a blind bit of difference what the Membership thinks or says. The Club will look at its usage figures, and if all is hunky dory, then it will just continue along the same path. If Site usage starts to dwindle, or it becomes apparent that there is a swing towards less use of energy, then the Club will possibly react in some way. It’s as simple as that. This is not a dynamic organisation……..

Posted on 29/11/2022 12:01

It depends on how we describe dynamic. That depends on the aims, objectives and principles behind any innovation. So, for the greens amongst us any dynamic action would be pend on less waste and more efficient end use. Now I’m not sure all members, particularly those grab what you can folk would see any dynamic aim or objective in limiting their use. Many of us would mind! How CaMC ensure non electric, moderate electric users and excessive users pay their way I’m not sure but it’s worth looking into in my opinion. 
Many moons ago I remember a suggestion that an adapter smart plug/meter could be hired on arrival which was returned, read in reception and charges made. Did that have mileage?  

JVB66 replied on 29/11/2022 12:11

Posted on 29/11/2022 12:01 by mickysf

It depends on how we describe dynamic. That depends on the aims, objectives and principles behind any innovation. So, for the greens amongst us any dynamic action would be pend on less waste and more efficient end use. Now I’m not sure all members, particularly those grab what you can folk would see any dynamic aim or objective in limiting their use. Many of us would mind!

Posted on 29/11/2022 12:11

I agree ,one only has to see what some put in the bins at club sites as managers will tell you it is not often that members even separate their recycling from other rubbish when on site even when there are notices above each bin  it all goes in the nearest bin

As one member next to us with a very upmarket outfit advised when the electricians were on site at FM he said  "if the club go down the route of metering my electricity usage I would not come to club sites"

replied on 29/11/2022 12:17

Posted on 29/11/2022 10:44 by Takethedogalong

I don’t share your heavy cynicism JV. The vast majority are good folks, minding their own business, happily staying legal and crime free.

What has changed is that there are now few systems in place, less staff and resources in place to actually catch the few who do push the boundaries. You can have as many rules, regulations, laws etc…. In place, but if there’s no one doing any monitoring, checking, patrolling, then it all falls apart. Organisations of all kinds are relying heavily upon technology too much, and even cutting costs in terms of utilising this as it should be. 

Posted on 29/11/2022 12:17

The user and all related content has been Deleted User

Takethedogalong replied on 29/11/2022 12:45

Posted on 29/11/2022 12:45

I was talking generally around different organisations and staffing, rather than just CAMC, sorry it wasn’t that clear.
Our last time out on a Club Site, which was newly refurbished Clumber, there were four staff on duty there. Very visible as well all around the Site, different times of the day, doing this that and the other. Smaller Sites, such as Marazion, Bromyard, Exeter Racecourse, usually two staff.
I’ve no doubts theft of all different kinds goes on, I know two non fixed shower heads disappeared on consecutive days at Yellowcraig, and toilet rolls are best locked into dispensers. But something like theft from a bollard would be a bit more visible, and there are some expert amateur detectives on Club Sites, willing to help out! 🤣

JVB66 replied on 29/11/2022 13:06

Posted on 29/11/2022 10:44 by Takethedogalong

I don’t share your heavy cynicism JV. The vast majority are good folks, minding their own business, happily staying legal and crime free.

What has changed is that there are now few systems in place, less staff and resources in place to actually catch the few who do push the boundaries. You can have as many rules, regulations, laws etc…. In place, but if there’s no one doing any monitoring, checking, patrolling, then it all falls apart. Organisations of all kinds are relying heavily upon technology too much, and even cutting costs in terms of utilising this as it should be. 

Posted on 29/11/2022 13:06

There are actually more site staff employed now than before the working time directive forced this clubs directors to have to employ more staff on sites to enable the hours even now to be covered ie 0800-2000 seven days a week plus an on call requiment and if any members complained it was the wardens who were normally in the wrong

I can remember a site warden at Top Lodge as it was then being suspended for hitting. a member and it was only because another member found out and complained to the club that it was properly investigated and the member who complained was found to be in the wrong

Before the WTD site staffs contracts I am reliably informed  were worded "as many hours as are needed to run your site " which at times would even mean accepting arrivals onto site at much later than the 2000hrs as now

The problems now are society as a whole it seems is going more towards "I have paid for this service so am going to get everything and more I can out of it"

And that is not just my take on it , most of those employed fronting todays public are of the same idea

Hja replied on 29/11/2022 13:08

Posted on 29/11/2022 12:17 by

I don't remember a time when the CAMC sites had that amount of staff. Its always been as few as they could get away with.

As I keep mentioning its common almost universal on continental sites ( there I have mentioned the forbidden wordwink) to ask at check in "do you require electricity?"

Various systems are in place 1: Meters rare    2: Locked boxes quite rare   3: honesty almost everywhere else.

I don't think these operators are mugs and allow wholesale theft of power but neither do I see any very obvious monitoring  (which must happen) taking place.

I personally always say yes and pay and in the certain knowledge more than a meter would charge. However  I hate meters with a vengeance not because I  want to use as much as I can but wondering how much of a bill we are running up does nothing to improve our holiday.

 

Posted on 29/11/2022 13:08

We haven’t taken a van abroad for a few years so things may well have changed. I do remember being asked what ampage we wanted, and that threw us of course because we were used to just plugging in! I remember meters in Germany and worrying what our bill would be. Again in a time when we didn’t really concern ourselves with electricity consumption and price per unit. The bill was never very high of course, largely battery charging and hot water. In later vans we had a microwave.

At  the time I remember us wondering if continental vans had less electrical items than uk vans, and a generally lower consumption. I wonder why many European sites use either different ampage or metering etc but uk sites have until recently just stuck with 16amp and no meters.

 

JohnM20 replied on 29/11/2022 13:35

Posted on 29/11/2022 13:35

We too have been on sites in France where each pitch was metered. One fairly large memorable site was as far back as 2008, and the meters didn't look new even then.

As regards people 'stealing' electricity by saying they didn't want a hook-up but then plugging in anyway, this would be quite easy to prevent. Put a locking cap on the EHU bollard. I guess that most pitch users will probably want electricity so the cost of a few locks for those that don't want the facility and the time taken for the warden to go to the pitch and put the lock on would be quite minimal in comparison with a meter.

On the other end of the scale, we have recently booked a CL that has just installed meters on their five pitches. They have just had to renew their electricity contract at eye watering figures per kW hence their decision to meter the supply. Rather strangely, they have a price for a basic pitch and no power used and then a second price for pitch using electric. Within this price is an allowance for 15kW per day power usage. Over or above the 15kW the users get an extra bill or a refund. Why it can't just be a cost for the basic pitch with a meter reading when arriving and another when departing and then charged accordingly I don't know. One thing that I'm fairly certain of is that we will never use 15kW per day so we should get a big refund. At home, using washing machines, tumble dryers, electric ovens etc etc we barely use 8 kW per day and a lot less mid summer. The owners may well re-consider this approach. Apparently they got the usage per day by Googling the question about usage. Somebody, somewhere, has got it very wrong I think.

near Malvern Hills Club Campsite Member photo by Andrew Cole

Book a late escape

There's still availability at many popular UK Club campsites - find your perfect pitch today for a last minute trip!

Book now
Woman sitting in camping chair by Wastwater in the Lake District with her two dogs and picnic blanket

Follow us on Facebook

Follow the Caravan and Motorhome Club via our official Facebook page for latest news, holiday ideas, events, activities and special offers.

Photo of Wast Water, Lake District by Sue Peace
Visit Facebook