UK sites with metered electricity

eurortraveller replied on 11/11/2021 09:59

Posted on 11/11/2021 09:59

Can people please post some examples of UK sites where electricity.usage is metered.

The one I know of is Pier Collage on the waterside at Coniston - a family owned site with 15 pitches . The system there is to pay on departure for the amount of electricity used, but other sites sell pre paid cards on arrival, so comments on the different ways of working may be helpful.

Likes and dislikes will inevitably crop up - they always do on here - but I was rather looking for practical ways of working. 

 

Tammygirl replied on 16/11/2021 21:08

Posted on 15/11/2021 21:01 by DavidKlyne

It does seem strange that there is no plan. Also thanks to Peedee for reminding us what was said four years ago and there doesn't seem to be any change since?

I suppose the club have three possible options.

1) They can continue to just add any increased utility costs to the site fees. Depending on the volatility of the energy market this could go unseen by many members as there is no correlation between rising energy costs and rising site fees that is published.

2) They could dampen demand for electricity by limiting the number of amps that are available to either 6 or 10. I suspect that would go over the heads of many members and probably cause more work for the wardens in trying to explain why they can no longer use the electrical items they once could. Whilst some members have said they can manage of a lower number of amps, something you are often forced to do when abroad, I suspect many members would prefer the easy life of not having to think about it?

3) They could introduce electricity metering which even the Club acknowledge would be the fairest way of charging for energy. Although in the longer term this would be the best option, logistically it is not without its problems. Even if the Club decided to go ahead it would be impossible to complete the task over a relatively short time so for quite a while you would have differences across the network. So anyone of a tour could encounter both metered and non-metered sites on a regular basis. Whichever way you look at it the cost would be massive and probably drain any refurbishment of sites budget for several years! We also don't know what will happen to our hobby in ten years time, will it be as popular as we get nearer to the point where ICE vehicles start to disappear? So its going to be a brave person who makes that decision?

David

Posted on 16/11/2021 21:08

Pretty much what I said up thread.smile

Government and Greens pushing for gas guzzling cars and vans to be off the road , means less tourers. Why would we need the pitches we have now.

The future is more cabins/pods/static vans. Moving from site to site in our electric cars.laughing

The money spent on meters would not be recouped, nice idea and I do think it would be the best way to go but like you said DK  who is going to make that decision.

DavidKlyne replied on 16/11/2021 21:17

Posted on 16/11/2021 16:54 by SeeFarers

Thank you peedee, I claim brain fade due to age.

However. I still think given the scenario I tried to paint is an extreme one, I believe the problem is not as big an issue requiring the investment that some are advocating and likely to be counter productive.

Posted on 16/11/2021 21:17

SeaFarers

I can't agree or disagree with you as we don't know the facts. If the Club would share with us the average pitch electricity usage with us for both summer and winter we would be in a better position to judge. Clearly some members are more frugal in their use than others. Also probably what one member does is possibly not reflective of what the membership does generally. Is it of any help to others if I say that I never leave the heating or water on in the van when we are out but when I return the heating is put on the 1800 watt setting where it stays, although it heats up in minutes. The only time I reduce the wattage is if I know I am on a site with a lower number of amps which is fairly rare in this country. For comparison at home I at this time of year I am using gas and electricity to the value of between £2.50 and £4 a day depending on how cold it is. Would that be an indication of what I use in my motorhome? If it is it doesn't seem too bad but without confirmation by the Club we don't know.

On the point of capital costs it would be large, probably about £200 a bollard which is £200000 on a 100 pitch campsite. On the other hand site bollards are being changed and upgraded all the time. Additional costs might depend of the method of recording and payment method. As a motorhomer you will understand some of our fellow owners can manage on site without mains electricity but currently have no choice, metering would give that choice.

David

peedee replied on 17/11/2021 07:40

Posted on 17/11/2021 07:40

Well I know how much I use because I have statyed on sites both here in the UK and on the Continent which use meters. Typically in the summer months it is 4Kw per day and has always cost less than £1 per day. In the winter using electic heating that can easily increase to over 24Kw a day or £6 to £7 per day. I have seen mention of 40Kw per day on here and one CL owner mentioned a customer using £8 per day!

I would think the Club does not know what the typical pitch usage is for the seasons unless they measure pitch consumption separately from site consumption. Unlikely in my view.

peedee

JVB66 replied on 17/11/2021 08:45

Posted on 17/11/2021 07:40 by peedee

Well I know how much I use because I have statyed on sites both here in the UK and on the Continent which use meters. Typically in the summer months it is 4Kw per day and has always cost less than £1 per day. In the winter using electic heating that can easily increase to over 24Kw a day or £6 to £7 per day. I have seen mention of 40Kw per day on here and one CL owner mentioned a customer using £8 per day!

I would think the Club does not know what the typical pitch usage is for the seasons unless they measure pitch consumption separately from site consumption. Unlikely in my view.

peedee

Posted on 17/11/2021 08:45

When meter readings are taken on sites several different readings are required from the meter and what I have seen they are not the same as what is fitted in the houses we have had

SteveL replied on 17/11/2021 09:26

Posted on 17/11/2021 07:40 by peedee

Well I know how much I use because I have statyed on sites both here in the UK and on the Continent which use meters. Typically in the summer months it is 4Kw per day and has always cost less than £1 per day. In the winter using electic heating that can easily increase to over 24Kw a day or £6 to £7 per day. I have seen mention of 40Kw per day on here and one CL owner mentioned a customer using £8 per day!

I would think the Club does not know what the typical pitch usage is for the seasons unless they measure pitch consumption separately from site consumption. Unlikely in my view.

peedee

Posted on 17/11/2021 09:26

I can well believe the higher figure. When we were away during one of the beast from the east, our heating set on 2kw never switched off, never reaching the 22C we had it set at. Add in some kettle, microwave and toaster usage and I suspect our usage would have been well over 40kw.

young thomas replied on 17/11/2021 10:06

Posted on 17/11/2021 10:06

So much for 'grade 3 insulation' a boldly made statement throughout the industry....

however, this 'test' (raising the internal temp to 25 deg when it's freezing outside) is only achieved by running the boiler on 4 or 6kw gas....how green is that.

despite what some say on here, 900w is pitiful to try and heat a large MH or caravan when it's freezing outside...

one of the best ways of getting good ramp up then easing back as things warm up is to use MIX....this uses gas (2 or 4 kw) and electric (900/1800w) until the temperature rises and then the gas eases back....to nothing...leaving the electric to maintain the desired temperature...

no need to be switching the unit around re fuel settings, just let it do its thing.

Cornersteady replied on 17/11/2021 10:19

Posted on 17/11/2021 10:06 by young thomas

So much for 'grade 3 insulation' a boldly made statement throughout the industry....

however, this 'test' (raising the internal temp to 25 deg when it's freezing outside) is only achieved by running the boiler on 4 or 6kw gas....how green is that.

despite what some say on here, 900w is pitiful to try and heat a large MH or caravan when it's freezing outside...

one of the best ways of getting good ramp up then easing back as things warm up is to use MIX....this uses gas (2 or 4 kw) and electric (900/1800w) until the temperature rises and then the gas eases back....to nothing...leaving the electric to maintain the desired temperature...

no need to be switching the unit around re fuel settings, just let it do its thing.

Posted on 17/11/2021 10:19

despite what some say on here, 900w is pitiful to try and heat a large MH or caravan when it's freezing outside..

I disagree, I've now idea about heating a MH and wouldn't resume to talk about them and perhaps a MH with all that glass in front to lose heat out would be pitiful? We have always had a large 6 six berth caravan and after warm up 900W is more than enough. In fact the heat thermostat is often at 3 out of 5 otherwise we're too warm, and yes that was was it was cold enough to freeze the water tap at the bollard.

I am certain you know what you talking about for MH but as you have never owned a caravan or even stayed in one how do you know?

Cornersteady replied on 17/11/2021 10:32

Posted on 17/11/2021 07:40 by peedee

Well I know how much I use because I have statyed on sites both here in the UK and on the Continent which use meters. Typically in the summer months it is 4Kw per day and has always cost less than £1 per day. In the winter using electic heating that can easily increase to over 24Kw a day or £6 to £7 per day. I have seen mention of 40Kw per day on here and one CL owner mentioned a customer using £8 per day!

I would think the Club does not know what the typical pitch usage is for the seasons unless they measure pitch consumption separately from site consumption. Unlikely in my view.

peedee

Posted on 17/11/2021 10:32

I would think the Club does not know what the typical pitch usage is for the seasons unless they measure pitch consumption separately from site consumption. Unlikely in my view.

Of course it is unlikely, impossible I would say, as to measure pitch consumption as that would require a meter at the pitch, would does not happen and will not happen for a good time yet. What you saying is I wonder how much a particular room uses in a house? What good is that?

Also there is the slight problem that while pitches remain in one place the people on it will change. One day you will have an outfit using 20Kw , the very next day (assuming same weather conditions) 10Kw?  So what is the point of knowing what a particular pitch will use?

But they will know site consumption certainly per month, perhaps even per day? then an average can be calculated and then let the central limit theorem do it's job.   

SteveL replied on 17/11/2021 11:06

Posted on 17/11/2021 10:19 by Cornersteady

despite what some say on here, 900w is pitiful to try and heat a large MH or caravan when it's freezing outside..

I disagree, I've now idea about heating a MH and wouldn't resume to talk about them and perhaps a MH with all that glass in front to lose heat out would be pitiful? We have always had a large 6 six berth caravan and after warm up 900W is more than enough. In fact the heat thermostat is often at 3 out of 5 otherwise we're too warm, and yes that was was it was cold enough to freeze the water tap at the bollard.

I am certain you know what you talking about for MH but as you have never owned a caravan or even stayed in one how do you know?

Posted on 17/11/2021 11:06

We have owned caravans, two of them. The first a 2004 Abbey, made by the Swift group, had the old truma blown air system with a convector fire below the wardrobe. This as well as keeping your coats lovely and warm, kept a fairly small van toasty on 900watts, once everything was warmed up, in all but the coldest weather. I don’t know what the insulation level was but the van was old style construction.

Our modern construction much larger 2014 Unicorn Cadiz with Alde heating was much different. Although the heating generally kept it lovely and warm, it did need the 2KW setting in cold weather. Otherwise it wouldn’t maintain 22C day 18C night.

Our MH has a Truma combi blown air, in cold weather 900watts isn’t sufficient to keep it pleasantly warm and the E2 1.8 KW setting is required. As long as the silver screen is used, I don’t think we loose a lot through the screen and front side windows. Overall I think we have less window area than our  Cadiz. 

Whittakerr replied on 17/11/2021 11:22

Posted on 17/11/2021 10:32 by Cornersteady

I would think the Club does not know what the typical pitch usage is for the seasons unless they measure pitch consumption separately from site consumption. Unlikely in my view.

Of course it is unlikely, impossible I would say, as to measure pitch consumption as that would require a meter at the pitch, would does not happen and will not happen for a good time yet. What you saying is I wonder how much a particular room uses in a house? What good is that?

Also there is the slight problem that while pitches remain in one place the people on it will change. One day you will have an outfit using 20Kw , the very next day (assuming same weather conditions) 10Kw?  So what is the point of knowing what a particular pitch will use?

But they will know site consumption certainly per month, perhaps even per day? then an average can be calculated and then let the central limit theorem do it's job.   

Posted on 17/11/2021 11:22

I think what Peedee meant was does the club know the electrical power consumption for all pitches on a site, as opposed to individual pitches, as well as the overall site consumption which would include the offices, site lighting, possibly water and space heating. Depending on the configuration of the electrical distribution system this would be easily achievable and would not require meters at the pitch bollard.

As for outfits using 20Kw or 10Kw that would be impossible. 10Kw would draw over 40amps and 20Kw over 80amps.

near Malvern Hills Club Campsite Member photo by Andrew Cole

Book a late escape

There's still availability at many popular UK Club campsites - find your perfect pitch today for a last minute trip!

Book now
Woman sitting in camping chair by Wastwater in the Lake District with her two dogs and picnic blanket

Follow us on Facebook

Follow the Caravan and Motorhome Club via our official Facebook page for latest news, holiday ideas, events, activities and special offers.

Photo of Wast Water, Lake District by Sue Peace
Visit Facebook