Pitch Prices

Geejay replied on 18/03/2023 08:57

Posted on 18/03/2023 08:57

I was thinking we might like to go to Oban, or nearby (we've been before), as there's a good off-road cycle track, which you can extend by catching the Corran Ferry and a quiet road on the other side.  There are two Club sites in the area, one at Onich and another at Barcaldine which are suitable.  I compared prices for 2 adults, 5 nights from 16th April, hardstanding with ehu: C&MHC Bunree £191; C&CC (with age concession) £107.

I wonder which one I should choose?

Takethedogalong replied on 19/03/2023 14:45

Posted on 18/03/2023 19:36 by eurortraveller

Good answer Tammy,  I won’t join the argument about this Cub’s prices versus that  Club’s prices. If I had a self contained motorhome I would be over to Fidden Farm on Mull. No bookings, no one turned away. I like that attitude. It appeals.

Posted on 19/03/2023 14:45

Superb recommend EuroT👍 Our kind of place, and it’s set us off dreaming I can tell you. 

Graydjames replied on 20/03/2023 14:41

Posted on 18/03/2023 13:12 by Geejay

“So what?”  We last stayed at Bunree in October 2020. Today’s price for the equivalent days (not dates) is £10 dearer per night for 2 people. £24 is now £34. I don’t think that’s a reasonable increase.  41% in 2 years. 

My criteria for choosing a site is that it has reasonable toilet/shower facilities and is convenient for walking/cycling straight from the site to do routes I have previously researched as suitable for our abilities. And it is rural. I’m not interested in the view as I live in a beautiful part of Scotland with an exceptional view and have previously lived in several such and have visited most parts of Scotland in my life, so a site with a view is a bonus but not essential. 

Price is not a criteria either unless I feel it is a rip off. Eg, a site we have been to before now charges £2 per dog per night.  We have 2 dogs so we won’t be going there again. 

Posted on 20/03/2023 14:41

Your second paragraph above entirely misses the point being made by those, like DK, for example, concerning the location and view comparison of the two sites you referred to. The view might not matter to you, but pricing is set for the wider market. It is inevitable that a site on the loch edge, and with one of the best viewpoints in the entire network, will be priced higher than those lacking those advantages.    

Prices are not set with your interests in mind.

The differential in this case, assuming your figures are correct, is a lot, I'll agree to that, but whether it is excessive is debateable, particularly as the CCC price is after a concession not available to all.  

Personally, I'd choose Bunree every time. I first went there in 1987 and have always thought of it as my all time favourite site, despite those pesky, but necessary, traffic lights which you begin to think will never change! North Ledaig is nice too, but Bunree is better. 

 

 

peedee replied on 24/03/2023 07:14

Posted on 24/03/2023 07:14

I have just booked a stay at the Cambridge C&CC site £15.80 per night cheaper, yes £15.80 per night difference than the Cherry Hinton site just three miles away! This is comparing like with like, hardstanding with 16 amp EHU. Even removing the over 60 discount there is still a huge difference. I have stayed on both sites before at varies times and if you know both, it is very hard to understand this difference? If I had used a grass without electric pitch at the C&CC site the saving would have been a massive £24.9 per night but with wet weather in the forcast I considered that too risky. I also looked at a nearby commercial site price, a bit further out from Cambridge centre, hardstanding 10 amp EHU, £26 per night so still a huge difference of £15+ per night but not so convenient.

At these differences the C&MC stands no chance of obtaining my patronage this year.

peedee

SteveL replied on 24/03/2023 08:29

Posted on 24/03/2023 07:14 by peedee

I have just booked a stay at the Cambridge C&CC site £15.80 per night cheaper, yes £15.80 per night difference than the Cherry Hinton site just three miles away! This is comparing like with like, hardstanding with 16 amp EHU. Even removing the over 60 discount there is still a huge difference. I have stayed on both sites before at varies times and if you know both, it is very hard to understand this difference? If I had used a grass without electric pitch at the C&CC site the saving would have been a massive £24.9 per night but with wet weather in the forcast I considered that too risky. I also looked at a nearby commercial site price, a bit further out from Cambridge centre, hardstanding 10 amp EHU, £26 per night so still a huge difference of £15+ per night but not so convenient.

At these differences the C&MC stands no chance of obtaining my patronage this year.

peedee

Posted on 24/03/2023 08:29

There is a huge difference when we are visiting as well, £9.80 on a two night stay if I remove the over 60’s discount to give a fair comparison. Not been before, but we don’t like Cherry Hinton, it is the only CAMC site we have visited that we wouldn’t go back to. There appears to be a regular bus into town, so it should suffice just as well.

DavidKlyne replied on 24/03/2023 09:10

Posted on 24/03/2023 07:14 by peedee

I have just booked a stay at the Cambridge C&CC site £15.80 per night cheaper, yes £15.80 per night difference than the Cherry Hinton site just three miles away! This is comparing like with like, hardstanding with 16 amp EHU. Even removing the over 60 discount there is still a huge difference. I have stayed on both sites before at varies times and if you know both, it is very hard to understand this difference? If I had used a grass without electric pitch at the C&CC site the saving would have been a massive £24.9 per night but with wet weather in the forcast I considered that too risky. I also looked at a nearby commercial site price, a bit further out from Cambridge centre, hardstanding 10 amp EHU, £26 per night so still a huge difference of £15+ per night but not so convenient.

At these differences the C&MC stands no chance of obtaining my patronage this year.

peedee

Posted on 24/03/2023 09:10

Obviously "Never Knowingly Undersold" doesn't apply!!! We like the C&CC Cambridge site as its more open and level. Access into town by bus not quite as good as Cherry Hinton although perfectly adequate and nowhere locally to walk to eat except a rather nice Garden Centre. However at that price difference if would certainly persuade me in favour of the C&CC site.

David

KjellNN replied on 25/03/2023 00:13

Posted on 18/03/2023 10:27 by brue

https://www.caravanclub.co.uk/certificated-locations/scotland/argyll--bute/oban/bioran-dubh-croft/

The CL I suggested is in a midway spot, the views around Port Appin are better than Bunree and there's a passenger ferry to the Isle of Lismore. Excellent walks and cycling too..take your bike to Lismore? A lot cheaper than the bigger sites but you can't price the experience.

Posted on 25/03/2023 00:13

It is in a lovely situation, but now charging £32 per night in June!

brue replied on 25/03/2023 08:44

Posted on 25/03/2023 00:13 by KjellNN

It is in a lovely situation, but now charging £32 per night in June!

Posted on 25/03/2023 08:44

 Gosh! Just checked it. Still prefer Port Appin though. wink

JollyKernow replied on 25/03/2023 08:54

Posted on 25/03/2023 08:54

What a nice cl, I'd happily pay £32 for that. Just reminds me how much we've got to see after we retire, not long nowlaughing

JK

richardandros replied on 25/03/2023 15:37

Posted on 25/03/2023 15:37

I have just booked 2 weeks at the C&CC site at Dartmouth in September and at £26 per night (with ACR), it seems very reasonable.  We usually stop off at Broadway for a couple of nights - going out and coming back but at £44 per night, I looked for alternatives.  We will be staying at the C&CC site at Blackmore instead (which is a nice site - we have stayed there before) and it's half the price of Broadway. Looks like this club, won't be getting any business from us this year.

SteveL replied on 26/03/2023 11:08

Posted on 26/03/2023 11:08

It does of course depend where you want to be, especially with a MH. Blackmore is certainly a substitute for Malvern Hills and we actually prefer it. However, for us preferring to leave the MH on site, it certainly can’t substitute for Broadway.

The club certainly don’t seem to have any problems filling flagship sites like Chatsworth, even with high prices and deposits. November is already approximately 60% full on all pitch types with still 7 months to go. There are certainly cheaper options, but none as convenient for just walking into the estate through the gate in the wall.

near Malvern Hills Club Campsite Member photo by Andrew Cole

Book a late escape

There's still availability at many popular UK Club campsites - find your perfect pitch today for a last minute trip!

Book now
Woman sitting in camping chair by Wastwater in the Lake District with her two dogs and picnic blanket

Follow us on Facebook

Follow the Caravan and Motorhome Club via our official Facebook page for latest news, holiday ideas, events, activities and special offers.

Photo of Wast Water, Lake District by Sue Peace
Visit Facebook