Motorhome facilities and rules

Each to their own opinion, what's perfect to one is less so to another or have I missed the irony

Agreed. They might be doing 'good' (well) in some areas but it's often difficult for a business to strike out in too many directions at one time.

as JVB points out, the pods are a separate business...however, outsourcing the WiFi hasn't been a huge success as even outsourced businesses need a service manager from the host to ensure that the paid for service is meeting all performance targets and costs...

I have no idea how the club decides, plans, resources, manages and delivers a network wide project like revamping MHSP.

perhaps it should just find the 'groundworks' equivalent of Air Angel and let them get on with it..

many on here know what makes a good MHSP....they use them regularly when abroad...yet I've still to see any repeating satisfactory standard being delivered...

perhaps there is no 'blueprint' and different areas are using different designs?

either way, its not happening at any great rate yet...

focus is what will get this delivered, not a piecemeal approach...it's fairly easy to see whether 'pods' or 'MHSP' is the higher priority...

I think most of these things are fairly easy to work out. Take motorhome service points. I am pretty sure the Club have probably completed the work on most sites they actually own or the work is planned in where refurbishments are in the pipeline. The problem is where the site is leased, a surprising number! I imagine the club wouldn't be keen putting new waste points in where they don't know from year to year if they will still be running the site. 

With WiFi I don't know what options the club have. I am pretty sure that it was the right decision to contract it out. I have been on non club  sites which use Camper Connect as a supplier which have provided perfectly reasonable WiFi but whether  they could cope any better with the demands of Club sites I have no idea. The trouble with WiFi is that the demands of the service have far outgrown the provision. I am not convinced that even the provision of 100GB connection will really solve the problem. Strangely we are currently on a no facility site with just a hotspot but almost outside the site City Fibre is laying fibre optics capable of at least 900GB if its the same as the City Fibre network at home. 

David

If the Club was designing a brand new Site from scratch, then it’s likely they could plan and deliver a very good MH service point. But they very seldom do this. Most of the improvements are carried out around existing, sometimes very old Sites, they have a lot of leased Sites, as DK points out. Or they are buying up existing Sites, and making do again with existing infrastructure. 

Dumping waste water, and filling up with fresh is such a tiny part of our overall holiday, in fact we seldom notice what’s on offer, and we certainly don’t base a stay somewhere on the MHSP. We deal with our fill and empty daily, so our waste tank never gets very full. We prefer it this way, makes life a lot easier. 

We visited some friends on the St Agnes beacon club site last week, firstly I was surprised at the level of occupancy for this time of year and  secondly the apparent number of pitches had increased since we last visited. It looked like a pack em in approach. I may be wrong but I didn't notice any extra facilities. In the past this site was rarely fully booked even in peak season due to the lack of a toilet block, a sign of staycation and changing demands possibly. 

Morning

Always amuses me peoples perception of increased pitch numbers on sites. Just for information, St.Agnes has lost 4 pitches, Marazion 2 pitches and Godrevy 1 pitch in the last year. There's been no increase in numbers in the 12 years I've been with the club in the south west.

Service point only sites have been rammed this year. I hope the club take this on board for future reference. This last fortnight we've been full with mainly motorhomes, the grass has stood up well.

JK

You have got me thinking there.  Facilities cost money - a lot of money.  Pitches make money. Modern caravans have on-board facilities (and ancient ones are allowed a toilet tent). So maybe instead of refurbishment, demolish and install more pitches? Could easily be fully serviced ones as the pipes are there.

either way, its not happening at any great rate yet...

focus is what will get this delivered, not a piecemeal approach...it's fairly easy to see whether 'pods' or 'MHSP' is the higher priority...

The above two statements make it sound as this is a definitive statement applicable to all club sites when really it is only from your perspective from the limited number (as you yourself have stated) of sites you have visited. It is not by any mean the complete picture that you're trying to suggest.

I think the opposite. Firstly you mention the rate? Now how is that (or even how do you) even measured or defined or what can one compared it to? Is the rate on non club sites far better? Secondly in the frequents flyer sites I use and many further afield across the country I've noticed new MHSP being installed from as along ago as four/five years and certainly after any refurbishment.

It is fairly easy to see whether 'pods' or 'MHSP' is the higher priority? Again you make this sound like a definitive statement but how? From what source or statistics are you basing this on? Any or just your gut feeling? It is far from easy to see across all sites. I think the two have gone hand in hand, in fact in my experience MHSP wee being changed before these glamping pods on 5 sites I can think of. But I can't/won't say that applies to all sites as you appear to do?

Of course all my experiences and observations only and I wouldn't make those applicable to all club sites but they do offer a differing viewpoint to and counters yours.

Darn it there’s always someone who rocks up with facts & truths to spoil the fake news spreaders of CT🤷🏻‍♂️😊

It is a crowded perception agreed, maybe the modern outfits are taking up a greater acreage over the last 25 yrs or so.