We have stayed at Yellowcraig many times over the last 8 years. It is really nice if you are after long beach walks, coldwater swims and dog friendly. Handy for the lovely town of N Berwick and a half hour from Edinburgh via bus or train from N Berwick. All the staff are excellent and keep the site clean and well looked after. The guy who does the lawns and hedges is clearly keen on what he does. My own (very picky) point would be that the showers are showing a bit of age now compared to say, the ones at Tantallone. All perfectly clean and hot with plenty of flow, but they could do with a revamp in the next few years with more modern cubicles. As a solar installer (!) it would be nice to see a move towards adding panels to feed the lights in the facilities and any path lights. A lot of sites are going this way - such as the Quiet Site by Ullswater - and it does look good.