A `proper` site - quiet, well placed, clean and spacious, but without looking like a car park or just having row upon row of regimented caravans. The numerous pitching areas give a choice for everyone, some hardstanding, some grassed, some pitched sideways. It gives the impression of a smaller site, but one with very generous pitches.  Wardens keep the site clean and tidy, and the facilities spotless, but I`d never call them `friendly`- efficient, yes, and good at their jobs but not welcoming.  The site was full with it being Bank Holiday, but didn`t feel crowded as some do, and the facilities were never overwhelmed. To be honest, my only complaint (as tends to be the norm at CC sites!) wasn`t with the site, wardens or facilities, but some of the people staying on it who let their offspring kick footballs about in the middle of a load of caravans - hitting more than a few when the owners were out. More than a few complaints were made to the wardens (not by me, I may add, as this was in an adjoining pitching area) who eventually put a stop to it. Never having been to this area before we were impressed with the beaches and general facilities in the area, only wished we had taken our bikes! The food at the Castle Inn was excellent and worth a visit, and if you play golf don`t forget to take your bats! One last point - follow the directions given by the CC when towing to the site, my sat-nav took me through the middle of North Berwick (again worth a walk - about 3 miles on the beach) including through a small car park. An interesting alternative, but not one I`d repeat by choice. We`ll definitely return, but with bikes and bats next time.

Comment from The Caravan Club:

Many thanks for taking the time to write a review and we are delighted to read that you enjoyed the site. The wardens work hard to ensure people have the best possible time at Yellowcraig and, as you can see from other reviews, are friendly and welcoming to guests on site. With regards to anyone breaking The Club Site rules, please do come and speak to the wardens as they are always happy to help resolve any issues, as they did in this instance. I hope this information is of help and thank you again for taking the time to write a review.