It's a shame you feel your holiday was spoilt in this way, LD,  but looking at your other reviews you don't seem to have a lot of luck seeking peaxe and quiet on (either) club's sites. Maybe you've just been unlucky because none of the other recent reviews mention a problem with dogs barking. As a dog owner myself I'm always aware of any possible nuisance - fortunately our dogs are placid and quiet - so we can be relaxed about it. I'm glad you acknowledge,  though, that the majority of dogs on site were quiet and well behaved. 

Have you thought of trying CLs? They are likely to be quieter and the owners often more pro-active in addressing such issues.

Oh my goodness, I’ve just seen the OP's other 5 year old thread has been resurrected. That’s several sites they’ve had noise problems on and won’t be revisiting. Unlucky, or what?

In reply to moulesy’s comments, you must be looking at a different web site to me as there are a number of reviews of the Sutton site mentioning problems with dogs. I only discovered this after I had posted my own review. It’s not the dogs fault, of course but rather the fault of those few irresponsible owners that fail to control their dogs. The majority of owners are more considerate. 

 Just looked back at the 20 most recent reviews on this very site LD. 3 other comments about dogs, one of which is quick to praise the warden for their prompt action in resolving an issue. Don't get me wrong, I have zero tolerance for owners who let their dogs bark/foul uncontrollably but unfortunately it happens, probably less on caravan sites than in general if the truth be known. I accept constant barking is irritating - we have a neighbour at home who, sadly, has such a dog. As I said, sorry you feel you had your holiday ruined, but my suggestion about CLs was one that we have found gives us a more enjoyable experience.  

These days with mobile phone being very technical it is easy to gather evidence of all issues to show the warden and to pass onto Head Office, 

Thanks for the positive advice and yes, we will try a CL in the near future. On a final note, in their response to my comments, the Club did say that complaints about dogs barking are the largest in number of all complaints.