We stayed at Edinburgh site from 3rd to 11th Sept 2017,and agree with other reviews that the site is excellently located for Firth of Forth for walking and off road cycling,and is only a short walk to the bus into Edinburgh which at £1:60 per journey beats taking and parking a car. The site and facilities are well cared for and the wardens are friendly and helpful. We must how ever point out the frequent and low aircraft approach to Edinburgh airport and unlike the other review which mentions only light air traffic and only in the day we must strongly disagree ,may be we were there at a different time of year but we had planes landing every 15 to 20 minutes during the day and the last one at night went in around 2:30 AM and they began again at 5:30 AM so only a 3 hour break during the night . We understand the club will not mention the aircraft traffic but we must make future visitors aware of the much disturbed nights we experienced. We will think twice before revisiting which is a shame .