this is the first time we have been to the Edinburgh site and as usual it was immaculate clean and friendly like all caravan club sites. It is perfectly positioned for a lovely walk or bike ride on the prom getting a bus into the city is simplicity itself just don't come back after dark as the path is pitch black and it would be a bit risky to walk down. we had a very enjoyable stay here but were grateful it was only for 3 nights as it is right on the flight path for the airport and the police helicopter seemed to be needed every night which was rather annoying. It is this noise intrusion that would stop us from returning