This is still one of our favourite and most visited site since we began caravanning in 2002! It is well positioned close to the Firth of Forth with an enjoyable walk along the promenade to Cramond (and Cramond Island when low tide) Always a warm welcome from the helpful and friendly wardens who have spent a lot of time and effort redressing the pitches .....the site is looking great! Facilities are good too.  Our only disappointment is that the public bus has stopped going round Marine Drive to the site entrance.To get into the city there is a mini bus from the site, or approx. 10 minute walk to the top road, but be aware there are no street lights on Marine Drive. . There are several supermarkets nearby. There is plenty to see and do in Edinburgh, but it is also a good location for day trips out of the city. We often visit The McArthur Glen designer outlet in Livingston and cross the Forth Road bridge to Fife (we especially enjoy the East Neuk fishing villages and St Andrews) We have just returned from another enjoyable visit and hope to be back again soon!