Quotes cannot be edited ?
8 replies
replied on 31/05/2017 13:08
moulesy replied on 31/05/2017 13:19
Tinwheeler replied on 31/05/2017 15:40
brue replied on 31/05/2017 16:02
DavidKlyne replied on 31/05/2017 16:41
Posted on 31/05/2017 16:41
Tony
I have moved your post here as it's the right place to discuss forum usability issues.
I would agree with TW and Brue regarding the reason. It's the same with having a limited time for users to edit their own post. I can understand that you might not want to quote a very long post just to answer one part of it and the copy and paste option mentioned by Moulsey is really the best option. Perhaps I could urge members to really consider if a quote is required in the first place. I can see if it's a technical subject but general discussions I am not always sure it is necessary?
David
Wherenext replied on 31/05/2017 19:42
Posted on 31/05/2017 19:42
David, without quoting you, I find that sometimes I am referring to or replying to a post that has several other posts between me and it and my post may make no sense in the flow of the topic without anchoring it with a quotation. Make any sense of that because it almost confused me?!
Otherwise I agree that the quoting of posts is not necessary but there are certain posters who use it all the time. Not sure what you can do.
Tinwheeler replied on 31/05/2017 20:35
Posted on 31/05/2017 19:42 by WherenextDavid, without quoting you, I find that sometimes I am referring to or replying to a post that has several other posts between me and it and my post may make no sense in the flow of the topic without anchoring it with a quotation. Make any sense of that because it almost confused me?!
Otherwise I agree that the quoting of posts is not necessary but there are certain posters who use it all the time. Not sure what you can do.
Posted on 31/05/2017 20:35
I quote for the very reason you've given, WN. I reply to you but a couple of other posts sneak in while I'm typing and the whole thing ends up as a nonsensical mess with no option to insert the quote via edit. At least we don't get 6 inches of quotes all down the page now.
TonyIshUK