Smart Meter

hostahousey replied on 10/02/2022 09:34

Posted on 10/02/2022 09:34

My energy company is wanting me to have a Smart Meter fitted. I wondered if anyone who has one could enlighten me on a few points'

Why do you need one ?

Where is it placed ?

Any upset fitting it ?

Does it Help ?

SteveL replied on 12/02/2022 12:44

Posted on 12/02/2022 12:11 by JohnM20

My biggest concern with smart-meters is the possible inaccuracy of them. I'm doing a daily check at the moment reading the gas cost and actual kWh and the same with the electric. If I then look at the weekly cumulative costs and usage they bear no resemblance to the figures if I add up the daily figures myself. Which is correct, the daily figures or the weekly ones? I suspect it is the daily figures but it would be nice if it was the weekly figures that are correct as they are much, much lower. What have the electric / gas company been billing me against?

Posted on 12/02/2022 12:44

What have the electric / gas company been billing me against?

It will be the actual meter reading, as sent by your meter, at the end of the charging period, minus the figure at the start. Just as it was when readings were sent manually or read by the meter readers. The costs shown on the display are a guide, I don’t think the intention is that you add them up. Ours also shows a monthly figure that seems accurate.

Rocky 2 buckets replied on 12/02/2022 12:49

Posted on 12/02/2022 12:11 by JohnM20

My biggest concern with smart-meters is the possible inaccuracy of them. I'm doing a daily check at the moment reading the gas cost and actual kWh and the same with the electric. If I then look at the weekly cumulative costs and usage they bear no resemblance to the figures if I add up the daily figures myself. Which is correct, the daily figures or the weekly ones? I suspect it is the daily figures but it would be nice if it was the weekly figures that are correct as they are much, much lower. What have the electric / gas company been billing me against?

Posted on 12/02/2022 12:49

I had similar issues years ago, I contacted the customer support, I finally got an answer weeks later & after numerous further requests for info. Apparently the figures were correct, what was not correct was the fact I was in credit not debit. They were increasing my monthly debit but not making the connection with the mistake. Eventually I got my overcharge back. I will no longer entertain BG as a fuel supplier. Put your questions to them(energy supplier) JM, keep at em use ofgem once you’ve exhausted their grievance procedure👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻

JohnM20 replied on 12/02/2022 13:48

Posted on 12/02/2022 13:48

Thanks, Rocky. I'm keeping detailed figures for the next three weeks as minimum and may continue through March when I can see what the monthly numbers are showing as well as the days and weeks. After that, if not before, I'll be on to EDF for an explanation.

JohnM20 replied on 12/02/2022 14:08

Posted on 12/02/2022 14:08

SteveL. The figures are vastly different between the days and week's figures. The daily usage for combined gas and electric is between about £3.00 and £3.75. The figure shown for the 'week' after 5 days is only £11.00. If the 5 daily figures are added together it should be £16.87 or thereabouts. The displayed kWh figures are even more unbelievable, out, by my calculation, by about 250 kWh. The worrying part is that these apparent 'errors' are not consistent. Something is wrong. If I had the display set to show just the weekly usage I could easily be led into a false sense of security - or are the weekly figures the correct ones.?

It comes down to, what is the point of having a display showing incorrect figures? Pointless in my opinion.

DavidKlyne replied on 12/02/2022 15:35

Posted on 12/02/2022 10:32 by JohnM20

To me, many of these 'gadgets' seem to be a very expensive way of flicking a switch. Taking Hive as an example, how long does it actually take to get a bit of warmth in the house if one has been away for a few days and come home and switch the CH on? Not long at all in reality. We leave our CH set at about 10º if we go away. This prevents any risk of frost damage but it very rarely switches on. Similarly with the hot water. Within a very short period it is back up to full temperature once switched on again. The house is well insulated so doesn't cool off to any major degree. During the summer months when most of us have our trips away the CH is probably fully switched off in any case.

I'm not a Luddite by any means, but I do consider carefully the benefits of buying any technology before I jump in. For many people, unfortunately, it is a case of The Emperor's New Clothes, believing anything that they are told.  Oh, the power of advertising.

My niece and her mother are gadget mad but the number of times she tells us "Oh I don't use that any more" when I ask about gadgets they have bought.

Cars are the same. I bet there is no-one on here that uses all the in-built gadgets and systems that modern vehicles offer - but we've paid for them.

Posted on 12/02/2022 15:35

John

I don't think I would have opted for the Hive system  as a stand alone purchase. However as we were changing to a Combi boiler and relocating it to a different position, the Hive system made perfect sense and has proved invaluable during the nearly three years we have had it. You have got to have some sort of control system so why not Hive and it has the advantage that I have access to my heating where ever I am.

I don't quite recognise the situation you mention in your first paragraph. Whenever we have returned to a cold house it has always taken it hours to get up to temperature, and I like to think we have a reasonably well insulated house. With our new system we increase the thermostat temperature when we leave the site and the house is nice and warm when we get back, couldn't be easier. I can also keep an eye on the house temperature whilst we are away and can adjust the schedule and temperature as required. 

On your point about accuracy. As far as the actual meters are concerned how would we know unless we either got very low or high bills which were out of line with the historical information we have from our old bills? I can't see there would be a difference between the new and old meters? As technology develops you would hope the newer meters would be spot on. The internal display is something different. As Steve says its really more of a means of identifying when energy usage changes and what appliances are on at the time causing that change. Some will be interested in that and others not. I sometimes wonder at what point the daily standing charge is added, even if it is to the daily usage?

David

Takethedogalong replied on 13/02/2022 12:02

Posted on 13/02/2022 12:02

We are in Luddite mode here. Our brand new, bluetoothed controlled, all singing, all dancing boiler developed a fault yesterday. We have hot water, but no central heating😡 Checked most things we could out, but no obvious problems, not airlocked, water circulating, etc.. So we think either it’s something in boiler, or signal unit is at fault. Engineer coming out tomorrow. Meantime, we ramped up the stove on tick over overnight, got the little oil filled heater out of MH for bedroom, and are fine. House overall is a liveable 17c, that’s just stove keeping things warm. Toasty in room with stove. Tech is wonderful, when it works. But when it don’t, give me Luddite for reliability🤣 And, think of the gas savings🤗

DavidKlyne replied on 13/02/2022 14:02

Posted on 13/02/2022 12:02 by Takethedogalong

We are in Luddite mode here. Our brand new, bluetoothed controlled, all singing, all dancing boiler developed a fault yesterday. We have hot water, but no central heating😡 Checked most things we could out, but no obvious problems, not airlocked, water circulating, etc.. So we think either it’s something in boiler, or signal unit is at fault. Engineer coming out tomorrow. Meantime, we ramped up the stove on tick over overnight, got the little oil filled heater out of MH for bedroom, and are fine. House overall is a liveable 17c, that’s just stove keeping things warm. Toasty in room with stove. Tech is wonderful, when it works. But when it don’t, give me Luddite for reliability🤣 And, think of the gas savings🤗

Posted on 13/02/2022 14:02

TDA

What sort of boiler is it? If its a Combi boiler my first suspicion would be whether there was enough pressure in the system? On our previous boiler it had a live feed, via a header tank, in the loft from the mains. The Combi is a sealed system but does need topping up from time to time. Hope you get it sorted PDQ.

David

Takethedogalong replied on 13/02/2022 17:25

Posted on 13/02/2022 14:02 by DavidKlyne

TDA

What sort of boiler is it? If its a Combi boiler my first suspicion would be whether there was enough pressure in the system? On our previous boiler it had a live feed, via a header tank, in the loft from the mains. The Combi is a sealed system but does need topping up from time to time. Hope you get it sorted PDQ.

David

Posted on 13/02/2022 17:25

Thanks DK. The pressure system was our first port of call, as it does, very occasionally, need a top up. It’s known here as “F1” as that’s the code that comes up, so topping up was first thing we did. It’s all a bit strange to be honest, as the thermostat display has the boiler ignited, and yes, it does ignite, but the central heating isn’t getting warm. So, is it the pump inside the boiler, we just don’t know. Reluctant to play with it beyond checking the obvious, as it has a ten year warranty on it, so we shall just let the engineer do his stuff.

It’s proven to be an interesting dilemma though, as the house is actually no colder with the stove lit, then when we use the central heating. Normally we don’t light the stove until we sit down in evening. But with doors closed to rooms we are not actually using today, and putting little oil filled radiator in bedroom for a couple of hours before bed, and leaving it on low overnight, with stove on tick over overnight, the house is fine without any other heating. So, it’s made us think a bit🤔 Use stove more, use CH a lot less. We are fortunate to have lots of clean burn wood available, and don’t mind budgeting for smokeless through year. So we know exactly what our heating costs, as it’s paid up front, or foraged for free. Admittedly, there is a bit of work involved in wood prep, but that keeps us fit and we both enjoy the novelty. Would be different of course if it was something we couldn’t do.

hostahousey replied on 14/02/2022 09:30

Posted on 14/02/2022 09:30

Getting back on track, think i'll stay as I am for the time being. Without a Smart Meter.

Bakers2 replied on 14/02/2022 09:44

Posted on 14/02/2022 09:30 by hostahousey

Getting back on track, think i'll stay as I am for the time being. Without a Smart Meter.

Posted on 14/02/2022 09:44

Smart move 😉

near Malvern Hills Club Campsite Member photo by Andrew Cole

Book a late escape

There's still availability at many popular UK Club campsites - find your perfect pitch today for a last minute trip!

Book now
Woman sitting in camping chair by Wastwater in the Lake District with her two dogs and picnic blanket

Follow us on Facebook

Follow the Caravan and Motorhome Club via our official Facebook page for latest news, holiday ideas, events, activities and special offers.

Photo of Wast Water, Lake District by Sue Peace
Visit Facebook