Be careful what you wish for!

LeTouriste replied on 28/03/2020 18:20

Posted on 28/03/2020 18:20

I was brought up as Christian and follow Christian principles, but I am an Agnostic.  My belief is in the power of Nature - not just our planet but the whole Universe.

A year or so ago I got into a discussion with friends about the problem of global warming, and my case for argument took me along the following path, as follows:

The Earth was not formed specifically for the benefit of Mankind - we simply evolved by accident along with all other species.  In fact, Mankind itself has become the greatest threat to life on Earth. My claim was that Nature would one day address the balance by producing some form of catastrophe. Annihilation of Mankind would only remove one species, and probably result in reducing the threat that now exists to many more.

I was speaking quite glibly at the time, and a few of the group were quite amused by my “prophecies”.   Now, with the advent of COVID-19, and its on going progress despite drastic actions by governments and medical science, I cannot help wondering if my comments about the power of Nature were a little nearer to the truth than I imagined. surprised

 

JVB66 replied on 30/03/2020 13:35

Posted on 30/03/2020 13:26 by Tinwheeler

What are you talking about, JV? It matters not whose home.

The message is clear - stay away!

Posted on 30/03/2020 13:35

OH dearundecided, how do these older relatives get their necesities?

Tinwheeler replied on 30/03/2020 13:40

Posted on 30/03/2020 13:35 by JVB66

OH dearundecided, how do these older relatives get their necesities?

Posted on 30/03/2020 13:40

Don’t show your pretended lack of understanding, JV. 

replied on 30/03/2020 13:47

Posted on 30/03/2020 13:30 by JVB66

Its like all the latest HMG "dictacs" it is a blanket instruction   ,that as usual  not a fits all circumstances ,undecided

Posted on 30/03/2020 13:47

I assume that some rely on general broad governmental advice and pay no attention to the advice of experts in the field to further consider the general advice JVB. I have in recent days spoken with 3 of my neighbours and all at a distance of 15 feet or more. Were we putting each other at risk in an open environment? Experts in the field say not. 

 

JVB66 replied on 30/03/2020 13:53

Posted on 30/03/2020 13:47 by

I assume that some rely on general broad governmental advice and pay no attention to the advice of experts in the field to further consider the general advice JVB. I have in recent days spoken with 3 of my neighbours and all at a distance of 15 feet or more. Were we putting each other at risk in an open environment? Experts in the field say not. 

 

Posted on 30/03/2020 13:53

You are probably right ,as i said the governments "rules" as so oft stated the guidance of wise men but the obeyance of otherswink

LeTouriste replied on 30/03/2020 15:10

Posted on 30/03/2020 11:53 by

We have had no one knocking on the door either but as we dont need anything we cant do for ourselves its not a problem and just hope those who do need help are getting it.

Posted on 30/03/2020 15:10

AD, like yourselves we are thankfully fit and able to take care of ourselves.  My comments about the apparent “neighbourly disinterest” were simply an observation, and I would imagine that there are many similar areas where the same disinterest exists.  Very sad for any vulnerable people living in such areas.

We stood on our doorstep at 8:00 pm last Thursday and joined in the applause for the NHS and other emergency services.  Clapping from nearby streets could be heard, along with a very few close to our home. You could say that this fits in with my previous comments about the lack of neighbourliness.

When I was a kid we lived in a district of terraced houses.  I was told to do little jobs or run errands for any aged neighbours, with strict instructions not to accept any money in reward.  Looking back, I am pleased to remember that this was accepted as normality. The principle has stayed with me ever since, and in recent years my wife has frequently warned me for helping someone where physical effort is unwise at my age.

Takethedogalong replied on 30/03/2020 15:30

Posted on 30/03/2020 15:30

I have just done my emergency delivery for my Mum. Pick up her meds from Pharmacy, knocked on door, left on doorstep, quick word from gate, all ok here and there, that will be it for a month, other than via social media contacts. I normally care two, three days every week for my Mum, who has dementia. My sister has taken the whole lot on, willingly, and we have a decent plan in place. All deliveries stop at the door, everything dealt with appropriately.  

I cannot imagine what someone in a similar condition to Mum, living all alone is going through at the moment. Our community has made sure anyone vulnerable, be they young or old, has contact details, or is being looked out for in whatever way helps. Even a wave through a window and a smile has enormous value at the moment.

replied on 30/03/2020 15:34

Posted on 30/03/2020 13:53 by JVB66

You are probably right ,as i said the governments "rules" as so oft stated the guidance of wise men but the obeyance of otherswink

Posted on 30/03/2020 15:34

I actually 'visited' my eldest daughter last week. She is at risk as she has had heart problems and is diagnosed as being in heart failure although recent tests have shown some improvements to her general condition. Much to her shame she was breathalysed at around 6.30am one morning a month ago and was just over the limit from a previous drinking session. She was suspended from driving for 12 months, given community service and a counselling session series on substance abuse. Originally the community service was to be in house removals but impossible for her. 9 months ago she had to sit on the bed to hoover her bedroom. So a place in a charity shop, She is supposed to visit her probation officer every two weeks (80 mins each way on public transport) and the counselling sessions (within walking distance) weekly I think. Counselling is now a 5 min phone chat and the probation officer visited her today. Communication was a wave through the window and 5 mins on the phone. 

My reason for travelling the 25 miles to daughters place and the 5 miles each way to hospital was to avoid her using public transport. Because OH had been in the passenger seat that morning to take her Yaris in to garage I provided gloves and I wore a face mask. 

What I found ridiculous was that she had a scan with staff in PPE but in the phlebotomist department she had to insist that the person taking the blood sample gloved up and wore a mask

Cornersteady replied on 30/03/2020 18:03

Posted on 30/03/2020 11:29 by LeTouriste

Oh dear - here we go with the argumentive element.    Mankind is itself an evolution of Nature. We have simply developed out ability to invent beyond that of the animal kingdom.  I did not say this particular pandemic would erase the human race, but it isn’t difficult to imagine what is possible in the future.

The world population has been increasing immensely.  One day we will run out of space, and we are using technology to artificially maintain ourselves.  If Armageddon did happen, it would be the so-called civilised races that would be the first to go.  The simple living folks in what’s left of the jungles would be the most able to survive.

Human behaviour in this pandemic Systematic clearing of shelves beyond what is needed, and the need for amounts per person to be controlled, clearly indicates how selfishly people would react. If an even more lethal virus engulfed the population, it is people themselves who would finish what a virus had started.

We are in our mid-80’s and, fortunately, able to be independent, although our families ring us daily to check that we are OK,  But, if we haven’t been seen for a few days, it hasn’t gone unnoticed that not a single neighbour has knocked on our door to check on us.  I would like to think that this attitude is a local one, rather than a general one countrywide.  A bit different to the days when neighbours helped each other in good times or bad.

Mankind is the single, most destructive species on the planet.  We have been indiscriminately exploiting the resources of the planet, and discarding our unwanted waste on the land, in the rivers and in the oceans.  Some of our rivers have been cleaned up, but this is only a small oasis for wildlife in a desert of detritus.  Ultimately, a price will be paid for this.

Anyone’s opinions about the future are purely surmise.  I hope that my negative thoughts are wrong, but certain behaviours by society do tend to make you look on the gloomy side.

Posted on 30/03/2020 18:03

I assume you posted your OP to get a discussion going and I have tried to discuss and to seek clarity of your thinking, that, with respect, appears to change from one post to the next. Is it 'argumentative' because some (all?) do not agree with you?

I can sort of see what your trying to say with nature doing checks and balances. The hunter prey system has been modelled very well using calculus - the hunter eats the prey and the hunter population goes up as the prey population goes down which lead to the hunter population going down which leads to the prey pollution going up and on and on... Relatively simple equations can predict what happens at any one moment in time.

So nature could balance the 'damage' done by humans (which was your first point). But now you appear to be saying that nature is working through us humans to self destruct?

A sort of nature saying: well the Bubonic Plague, didn't do a good enough job so let's just switch humans' intelligence on a bit and get them to do it instead? 

That to me is just nonsense and I just don't agree with your idea that there is a guiding force like the one you describe, sorry though that no one has checked on you, perhaps just something local, plenty round here have.

Stay safe

 

replied on 30/03/2020 18:25

Posted on 30/03/2020 18:25

The user and all related content has been Deleted User

JVB66 replied on 30/03/2020 19:01

Posted on 30/03/2020 15:30 by Takethedogalong

I have just done my emergency delivery for my Mum. Pick up her meds from Pharmacy, knocked on door, left on doorstep, quick word from gate, all ok here and there, that will be it for a month, other than via social media contacts. I normally care two, three days every week for my Mum, who has dementia. My sister has taken the whole lot on, willingly, and we have a decent plan in place. All deliveries stop at the door, everything dealt with appropriately.  

I cannot imagine what someone in a similar condition to Mum, living all alone is going through at the moment. Our community has made sure anyone vulnerable, be they young or old, has contact details, or is being looked out for in whatever way helps. Even a wave through a window and a smile has enormous value at the moment.

Posted on 30/03/2020 19:01

Your "Visit" to your mother is just the caring "visit" is what i would consider an essential journey, and  happens in this area and many others i would expect,  at this very dangerous times ,

Although some posters would not want that to happen by  their posts

 

near Malvern Hills Club Campsite Member photo by Andrew Cole

Book a late escape

There's still availability at many popular UK Club campsites - find your perfect pitch today for a last minute trip!

Book now
Woman sitting in camping chair by Wastwater in the Lake District with her two dogs and picnic blanket

Follow us on Facebook

Follow the Caravan and Motorhome Club via our official Facebook page for latest news, holiday ideas, events, activities and special offers.

Photo of Wast Water, Lake District by Sue Peace
Visit Facebook