Towcar of the Year winner announced

EmilysDad replied on 12/10/2017 19:27

Posted on 07/10/2017 17:32 by reynoray

So what does Tow Car of the Year tell us?  As usual it says that a car costing £27000 is the best tow car (or £35000 and more for a Range Rover etc etc.). How does that help the vast majority of us who could never dream of owning cars of these prices?  I know that many reading this could buy one in a flash but most could not.  So how do we respond to the news that that is what we need?  Go green with envy and wait a number of years until we can afford a second hand one? (and feel we have a less than perfect life in the meantime?).  It's a pointless bit of information for most of us that some people who are paid just to have something to say put out.  I have a car that cost what I could afford and a very nice caravan in which we enjoy brilliant times.  My car tows perfectly for me and I never wish "ooh I wish I had this or that better car".  A pointless exercise for me and I suspect the majority of other caravaners.  Rant over smile

 

Posted on 12/10/2017 19:27

I'm not envious of any of the tow cars I see see on site. My tow car was 5 yrs old when I bought it about 5 yrs ago. I believe it was £45/50k new ..... no way would I pay that for a car,  but I'm quite happy to let others take the hit on depreciation & buy my cars 2nd hand. 

TimJim replied on 13/10/2017 12:22

Posted on 13/10/2017 12:22

As MollysMummy says eloquently very often brand new ain't the best way forward...it's not just the obvious depreciation...often newer models have essential towing kit missing.....several makers new models have dropped self levelling for an extra 20bhp for instance and also modern diesels are hamstrung by dpfs  and  ad blu  nonsense ...as the old Tunes adverts says diesels  breath easier without all that b*****ks....

Tj

replied on 13/10/2017 13:39

Posted on 07/10/2017 17:32 by reynoray

So what does Tow Car of the Year tell us?  As usual it says that a car costing £27000 is the best tow car (or £35000 and more for a Range Rover etc etc.). How does that help the vast majority of us who could never dream of owning cars of these prices?  I know that many reading this could buy one in a flash but most could not.  So how do we respond to the news that that is what we need?  Go green with envy and wait a number of years until we can afford a second hand one? (and feel we have a less than perfect life in the meantime?).  It's a pointless bit of information for most of us that some people who are paid just to have something to say put out.  I have a car that cost what I could afford and a very nice caravan in which we enjoy brilliant times.  My car tows perfectly for me and I never wish "ooh I wish I had this or that better car".  A pointless exercise for me and I suspect the majority of other caravaners.  Rant over smile

 

Posted on 13/10/2017 13:39

Where do you find all these vast, most and the majority "statistics" from ?

Or are they made up to put your point across ?

H1UBS replied on 15/10/2017 18:30

Posted on 07/10/2017 09:51 by Fysherman

Now realised you cannot have a kodiak with 100kg noseweight and any kind of spare wheel. Totally useless then as a serious tow car.

Ridiculous that the CC made it  tow car of the year. 

Posted on 15/10/2017 18:30

I can confirm the 5 seat version of the 2.0 tdi 190 has a nose weight limit of 100kgs, and a towing mass of 2500kg.

Correct, you can't have a spare wheel from the Skoda factory on some but you can buy them elsewhere for £160. I have, and will keep it under the bed in the caravan when towing.

https://www.thewheelshop.co.uk/skoda-kodiaq-18-space-saver-spare-wheel-tool-kit.html

It is a great tow car with the right specification.

Huwrhys replied on 09/11/2017 18:11

Posted on 09/11/2017 18:11

I may be late to the topic but this is my first posting. 

I have a Discovery 4 3.0ltr diesel HSE and have been over the moon with the towing performance of this car. My assumption was that I would naturally progress to the 5 when it came along but the diesel haters have got me thinking. I live within the M25 and fall within the LEZ as was. I'm reliably informed that the actual LEZ for which cars are being charged is the same as the congestion charge zone, known as the ULEZ (Ultra Low Emission Zone). Beyond that any EU4 diesel vehicles are being phased out. 

Now being a tow car I need it to be able to tow my not inconsiderate 2500kg caravan all over Europe every year without the inconvenience of having to charge a battery every 200 miles. Petrol is way too expensive to provide the required power without needing a following tanker to keep it fed. PHEV looked to be the answer. I was interested to see the XC90 T8 win the heavyweight class as I had already looked at the Volvo some months ago and the interior of the posh one is an absolute delight. BUT how can they show it to be top of it's class when no one has tried it with a dead battery. A 2.0ltr petrol (even a 345bhp one) is not going to pull my van up a mountain in Austria without blowing a gasket. I can't think of anywhere where I can charge the car whilst touring. Sites are generally low amperage affairs in Italy and France without the required ooomph to get the car sorted if the van's plugged in. I just can't see the award going to a car which just hasn't been tested to work once the charge has depleted. I think for my own case, I'll stick to diesel until a more thought out remedy is found to replace my current type of motivation.

Disco 5 is actually really good at all it has to do.

H1UBS replied on 20/12/2017 20:34

Posted on 20/12/2017 16:07 by davebakerpurton

And with the factory fit tow bar, no pin 10-11 wired up, so no fridge

Posted on 20/12/2017 20:34

Your information is incorrect. If you own one with this problem suggest you have a warranty claim. 

I do own one and it all works fine exactly per the EU standard and specification that all such sockets must comply with.

davebakerpurton replied on 20/12/2017 22:20

Posted on 20/12/2017 20:34 by H1UBS

Your information is incorrect. If you own one with this problem suggest you have a warranty claim. 

I do own one and it all works fine exactly per the EU standard and specification that all such sockets must comply with.

Posted on 20/12/2017 22:20

That's strange, I own one and pins 10-11 aren't wired up, when I contacted Skoda they said that's the way they do it

xtrailman replied on 21/12/2017 07:47

Posted on 21/12/2017 07:47

I would check the latest brochure things may have changed, the tig is defiantly fully wired with the factory bar. it's mentioned in the brochure.

near Malvern Hills Club Campsite Member photo by Andrew Cole

Book a late escape

There's still availability at many popular UK Club campsites - find your perfect pitch today for a last minute trip!

Book now
Woman sitting in camping chair by Wastwater in the Lake District with her two dogs and picnic blanket

Follow us on Facebook

Follow the Caravan and Motorhome Club via our official Facebook page for latest news, holiday ideas, events, activities and special offers.

Photo of Wast Water, Lake District by Sue Peace
Visit Facebook