Caravanning without a towcar

Rob COurt replied on 20/08/2020 05:41

Posted on 20/08/2020 05:41

We have just been informed that our tow car (MPV style Peugeot 5008) does not have the capacity to legally tow our caravan. As we are not in a position to replace it yet we're looking at alternatives for holidaying with our caravan.

Does anyone have any experience of the following options and/or would be able to provide advice?

1) Hiring a tow car : we're looking at quotes in the region of £300/week.

2) Caravan transport: arranging shipment of caravan to the site and back again.

3) Seasonal pitch (possibly prohibitively expensive) with caravan transported to the site.

I'm sure there may be other options we've not thought of? 

Many thanks!

Rob

Rob COurt replied on 20/08/2020 17:15

Posted on 20/08/2020 17:15

Firstly, thank you for all the responses. Secondly, my apologies for the lack of clarity in the original post. Having looked into it I'm fairly confident that our car should not be towing our caravan.

We bought our first caravan 3 years ago having bought the 63 plate Peugeot 5008 (2.0L HDi 163 horsepower automatic Allure) with the intention of using it as a tow car. The caravan dealer assured us that our car would be a suitable tow car pointing out the kerbweight of 1694kg. Our caravan is a 2005 Abbey Aventura 317 with max laden weight of 1304kg (77% of our car's kerbweight). 

We were nervous of towing and have regularly checked our carvan's weight using a weighbridge and packed carefully keeping an eye on the noseweight. We have always driven carefully and have never had a problem in the three a bit years of touring. 

We were considering a larger caravan to accommodate our growing daughters and my wife was checking with a dealer whether our car was a match when he introduced us to towing capacity. He entered our car registration into their 'computer' and it came back with a maximum towing weight of 1200kg. As I understand it towing with this set up invalidates our insurance and is not legal. On checking the car's plate we found that gross train weight - gross vehicle weight was 3530 kg - 2330 kg = 1200 kg.

We've looked for four berth caravans under 1200 kg and have investigated changing our car early which we can't afford at this point in time. We've looked at hiring tow vehicles (which is a possibility) and using a caravan delivery service (which is too expensive to be practical) but, to cut a long and rambling explanation short, I was wondering whether anyone had a plan C! Perhaps we need to follow Jill's suggestion and make friends with someone with a towcar!

Thanks again.

Rob

Freddy55 replied on 20/08/2020 17:37

Posted on 20/08/2020 17:37

I just thought I’d mention...

For practical reasons, we went without a tow car for a few years. I got a friend to tow the van to a campsite near Newton Abbot (Twelve Oaks). The arrangement was that they would store it for me, and put it on a pitch when we wanted to visit. From memory, the storage costed around  £400 a year, with a £10 charge each time it was pitched, pitch fees on top. I’m pretty sure other campsites offer the same service.

Rob COurt replied on 20/08/2020 17:45

Posted on 20/08/2020 17:45

Good point, thank you Freddy.

We've got a quote from a nearby campsite for £1000 for the season (Mar-Oct) but they're open to negotiation!

Rob

replied on 20/08/2020 17:47

Posted on 20/08/2020 17:15 by Rob COurt

Firstly, thank you for all the responses. Secondly, my apologies for the lack of clarity in the original post. Having looked into it I'm fairly confident that our car should not be towing our caravan.

We bought our first caravan 3 years ago having bought the 63 plate Peugeot 5008 (2.0L HDi 163 horsepower automatic Allure) with the intention of using it as a tow car. The caravan dealer assured us that our car would be a suitable tow car pointing out the kerbweight of 1694kg. Our caravan is a 2005 Abbey Aventura 317 with max laden weight of 1304kg (77% of our car's kerbweight). 

We were nervous of towing and have regularly checked our carvan's weight using a weighbridge and packed carefully keeping an eye on the noseweight. We have always driven carefully and have never had a problem in the three a bit years of touring. 

We were considering a larger caravan to accommodate our growing daughters and my wife was checking with a dealer whether our car was a match when he introduced us to towing capacity. He entered our car registration into their 'computer' and it came back with a maximum towing weight of 1200kg. As I understand it towing with this set up invalidates our insurance and is not legal. On checking the car's plate we found that gross train weight - gross vehicle weight was 3530 kg - 2330 kg = 1200 kg.

We've looked for four berth caravans under 1200 kg and have investigated changing our car early which we can't afford at this point in time. We've looked at hiring tow vehicles (which is a possibility) and using a caravan delivery service (which is too expensive to be practical) but, to cut a long and rambling explanation short, I was wondering whether anyone had a plan C! Perhaps we need to follow Jill's suggestion and make friends with someone with a towcar!

Thanks again.

Rob

Posted on 20/08/2020 17:47

As far as I ma aware the maximum train weight means that from a legal point of view as long as the actual combination weight does not exceed 3,530kg then you are legal regardless of maximum vehicle weight. For licence categories it is based on Max vehicle weight. For other purposes it is actual weights.

replied on 20/08/2020 17:48

Posted on 20/08/2020 17:37 by Freddy55

I just thought I’d mention...

For practical reasons, we went without a tow car for a few years. I got a friend to tow the van to a campsite near Newton Abbot (Twelve Oaks). The arrangement was that they would store it for me, and put it on a pitch when we wanted to visit. From memory, the storage costed around  £400 a year, with a £10 charge each time it was pitched, pitch fees on top. I’m pretty sure other campsites offer the same service.

Posted on 20/08/2020 17:48

Many do

Rob COurt replied on 20/08/2020 19:22

Posted on 20/08/2020 19:22

Hi Allen and Jean. Thank you for that - I had a look and it certainly seems that it may not be as clear cut. Just to be clear, looking at the numbers...

GTW = 3530 kg = caravan and car can't exceed this?

GVW = 2330 kg = car can't exceed this regardless of being solo or towing?

Digging out the weighbridge ticket from when we went to Norfolk earlier this month, car = 2130 kg, caravan = 1300 kg. 

As the combined total is less than the GTW does this make it road legal? And the caravan mass is still well within 85 % kerb weight. I think this is the point that EasyT was making?

From what my wife says the person in the dealership was pretty adamant that towing anything over 1200 kg would categorically be illegal and invalidate our insurance. I think we may go back to the dealer for clarification. 

Thank you for your patience!

allanandjean replied on 20/08/2020 20:42

Posted on 20/08/2020 20:42

Hi Rob, You latest post figures seem to confirm that the outfit is ‘legal’.

Who knows why/how the dealer arrived at their figures-a simple mistake maybe-but it looks OK.

near Malvern Hills Club Campsite Member photo by Andrew Cole

Book a late escape

There's still availability at many popular UK Club campsites - find your perfect pitch today for a last minute trip!

Book now
Woman sitting in camping chair by Wastwater in the Lake District with her two dogs and picnic blanket

Follow us on Facebook

Follow the Caravan and Motorhome Club via our official Facebook page for latest news, holiday ideas, events, activities and special offers.

Photo of Wast Water, Lake District by Sue Peace
Visit Facebook