Member demograph
58 replies
DavidKlyne replied on 30/09/2016 09:53
Posted on 30/09/2016 09:53
So, it's a photo of our Club's elected Executive Council. Yes?
I have scoured the Club website for the minutes of their recent meetings, or even a summary of the decisions they have taken, but I don't seem to be able to find anything Can someone give me the link please.
Surely they don't meet in secret and make decisions without telling members. That wouldn't be how a Club operates, would it?
ET
If you go here you can see the AGM minutes going back several years and there is also a link to how the Club is run and the various committees. I don't know that the minutes of those committes are actually published. There are a fair number of them and I can just see the compalints if the magazine was full of committee reports each month!!! I assume the AGM minutes is a precis of the combined committee reports?
David
DavidKlyne replied on 30/09/2016 10:03
Posted on 30/09/2016 10:03
I thnk it's profoundly depressing to see the narrow demographic represented here. It positions the CC as a deeply old-fashioned, conservtive (with a small c), organisation. If our hobby is to thrive and grow into the future, surely it needs to attract a wider demographic, much more representative of the UK population. If the public perceives CC as owned, run, staffed, and in existence only for white, suited, balding, middle-agd men, and ok maybe the occasional woman, then it cannot expect and will not deserve to flourish in the future. I believe that the Club is very forward looking in many ways - it's a sound business that - and I can only speak as I find as a member (customer?!) for over 15 years - has invested well and works very hard to deliver hgh levels of customer satisfaction. However, I do think that it is legitimate to criticie it on its apparent atitude to diversity.
I wonder if the Management under the Director General is a counter balance in terms of age? I am sure many of those in senior management roles are in a younger age group than the members in the photograph. I am sure that decision making is a two way process and the paid management will be more aware of areas causing difficulties to the general running of the Club.
David
JVB66 replied on 30/09/2016 10:20
Posted on 30/09/2016 10:20
So, it's a photo of our Club's elected Executive Council. Yes?
I have scoured the Club website for the minutes of their recent meetings, or even a summary of the decisions they have taken, but I don't seem to be able to find anything Can someone give me the link please.
Surely they don't meet in secret and make decisions without telling members. That wouldn't be how a Club operates, would it?
ET
If you go here you can see the AGM minutes going back several years and there is also a link to how the Club is run and the various committees. I don't know that the minutes of those committes are actually published. There are a fair number of them and I can just see the compalints if the magazine was full of committee reports each month!!! I assume the AGM minutes is a precis of the combined committee reports?
David
..It could, sorry would outstrip Sunday deps.thread
eurortraveller replied on 30/09/2016 10:31
Posted on 30/09/2016 10:31
DK. Thank you for such a prompt reply. So the photo is not the full Council and must be the Excutive Committee - which meets nine times a year. The real movers and shakers.
If not the full minutes of those nine meetings I think a summary of the decisions they have taken could well be posted on line - rather than just the once a year report at the AGM. It's the fundamental difference between the running of a Club and a commercial company, isn't it. Boards of Directors meet in commercial confidence, but Clubs are open about the things they do.
Fysherman replied on 30/09/2016 10:34
eurortraveller replied on 30/09/2016 10:41
volvoman9 replied on 30/09/2016 11:33
DavidKlyne replied on 30/09/2016 12:41
Posted on 30/09/2016 12:41
It's not a club really is it.
Its not been a "club" in the true sense of the word for a long time.Its a leisure business nowadays for which we as members get a small discount on the products and services.
v9
That analysis might be right if someone other than Club members had the benefit from any profits made. But, as all profits are put back into the Club for the benefits of members how is it not a Club? There is a difference between an organisation being run in business like way, through sheer size and it not also being a club. Also the structure of the management of the Club points to it not being a business in the accepted sense of the word as the executive are elected. I would be interested to know how many businesses are run like that.
David
Hicap replied on 30/09/2016 13:03
Posted on 30/09/2016 13:03
I thnk it's profoundly depressing to see the narrow demographic represented here. It positions the CC as a deeply old-fashioned, conservtive (with a small c), organisation. If our hobby is to thrive and grow into the future, surely it needs to attract a wider demographic, much more representative of the UK population. If the public perceives CC as owned, run, staffed, and in existence only for white, suited, balding, middle-agd men, and ok maybe the occasional woman, then it cannot expect and will not deserve to flourish in the future. I believe that the Club is very forward looking in many ways - it's a sound business that - and I can only speak as I find as a member (customer?!) for over 15 years - has invested well and works very hard to deliver hgh levels of customer satisfaction. However, I do think that it is legitimate to criticie it on its apparent atitude to diversity.
I wonder if the Management under the Director General is a counter balance in terms of age? I am sure many of those in senior management roles are in a younger age group than the members in the photograph. I am sure that decision making is a two way process and the paid management will be more aware of areas causing difficulties to the general running of the Club.
David
The Club has an Equality & Dversity Policy, published on the website, which is good to see. For me, this issue is about PERCEPTION. How many Black, Asian & Minority Ethnic wardens are employed? How many Black, Asian & Minority Ethnic caravanners do you see staying on Club sites? Vey few in my experience. Of course this is all anecdotal. It just does not FEEL inclusive to me, reflected in the photographs one sees on the site and in the magazine, of exective council members, staff etc. Please be clear: I am not accusing the Club of racism; I'm saying that I think the Club would benefit from consideing how it presents itself and looks to attract new customers and members for the future, maximising the appeal of the hobby and the insitituition, all for the benefit of securing the future.
Fysherman replied on 30/09/2016 13:18
Posted on 30/09/2016 13:18
It's not a club really is it.
Its not been a "club" in the true sense of the word for a long time.Its a leisure business nowadays for which we as members get a small discount on the products and services.
v9
That analysis might be right if someone other than Club members had the benefit from any profits made. But, as all profits are put back into the Club for the benefits of members how is it not a Club? There is a difference between an organisation being run in business like way, through sheer size and it not also being a club. Also the structure of the management of the Club points to it not being a business in the accepted sense of the word as the executive are elected. I would be interested to know how many businesses are run like that.
David
I liken it to the major charities David.
A full blow business run for beneficiaries other than shareholders.
mbee1